BALEN VS SETO TOWER aka Dharahara

 The New Dharahara: A Symbol of Resilience, Not Just a "Seto Tower"

​The controversy sparked by Kathmandu's Mayor, Balen Shah, calling the newly rebuilt Dharahara a "Seto Tower" (White Tower) has ignited a passionate debate. While his intention may be to criticize what he sees as a flawed urban development project, his words have struck a nerve for me because I consider this as a grave disservice to our history and ancestors.

​The argument is simple: calling the new Dharahara a generic "white tower" is profoundly inappropriate. It dismisses the monument's historical significance and the extraordinary circumstances that led to its reconstruction.

​The Reality of Rebuilding After a Catastrophe

​The 2015 earthquake was a devastating natural calamity, not a man-made error. It leveled our beloved Dharahara. When faced with rebuilding such a crucial symbol, the use of modern materials and tools was not a choice of aesthetic preference; it was a non-negotiable necessity.

​We no longer have the "old sand" or the same materials and techniques used by our ancestors centuries ago. More importantly, it would be irresponsible to rebuild a tall structure in an earthquake-prone zone without incorporating modern, earthquake-resistant engineering. The steel and concrete used in the new Dharahara are not a betrayal of our past; they are a pragmatic adaptation to ensure the structure's safety and longevity for generations to come.

​A Symbol of Our Ancestors' Vision

​The new Dharahara, despite its modern components, stands as a testament to our ancestors' concept and vision. It occupies the same sacred ground and retains the iconic shape that they first envisioned. It is a powerful symbol of continuity and resilience, showing that even when faced with the harshest natural forces, we honor and rebuild what was lost.

​To label it merely a "Seto Tower" is to ignore this profound continuity. It disrespects the countless engineers, laborers, and citizens who poured their hearts and efforts into bringing this symbol back to life. More deeply, it risks defaming the very legacy of our ancestors by trivializing their architectural genius and historical contributions.

​The Dharahara is more than just a physical structure. It is a living monument that embodies our nation's spirit, resilience, and unwavering pride in our history. Let's appreciate it for what it is—a bridge between our past and a safer, more resilient future.